This Fan-Favorite Coffee Mate Flavor Is Coming to Stores for the First Time Ever

We’ll admit, some of the flavors Coffee mate comes out with—especially the limited-time releases—make us do a double take. Don’t get us wrong, we’re not coffee purists. We happily stir in some pumpkin spice sweetness every fall and dive headfirst into peppermint mocha as soon as Thanksgiving rolls around. But there are a few combinations that just feel a bit outside the coffee box.

However, every now and then, Coffee mate’s creative genius gets it just right. One 2023 special-edition creamer was so good, fans demanded its return—and Coffee mate delivered.

Coffee Mate’s Peanut Butter & Jelly Duo Creamer Is Back

Right now, your taste buds might be wrapped up in gingerbread, peppermint, or sugar cookie, and we get it. Those flavors are seasonal staples we look forward to all year long. But thanks to Coffee mate’s latest launch, it’s officially peanut butter jelly time in our minds.

That’s right—the fan-favorite Peanut Butter & Jelly Duo creamer is returning. And for the first time ever, it’s coming to retail stores.

Peanut butter and jelly is one of those classic combos almost everyone grew up loving. So why not carry that nostalgia into adulthood—through your coffee cup? Coffee mate’s PB&J Creamer combines the nutty, fruity flavors you know and love in a new way. “The jelly sweetness perfectly complements the delicious flavor of creamy peanut butter to deliver a one-of-a-kind coffee experience,” Coffee mate shared in an email statement.

The creamer originally debuted last year as a giveaway-only flavor, but it turned out to be so popular that fans begged for its return.

Unlike Coffee mate’s traditional flavors like hazelnut or French vanilla, the Duo line is all about pairing two complementary tastes in one bottle. The PB&J creamer joins other Duo flavors like Vanilla + Cinnamon and Vanilla + Caramel, doubling down on richness and creaminess in every cup.

The 16-ounce bottle can be used in both hot and iced coffee drinks, but fans are already coming up with other creative ways to enjoy it. One commenter suggested stirring it into oatmeal, while others are imagining it as a dessert ingredient.

Since the announcement, excitement has been building online. Newbies are eager to try it, with comments like, “OMG NEED” and “SOOOO EXCITED TO TRY THIS.” Meanwhile, fans in the know are thrilled to see the flavor unexpectedly return, sharing reactions like, “This is not a drill!” and “Praise the coffee overlords!”

The Peanut Butter & Jelly Duo Creamer will officially hit select stores in January 2025. It’s non-dairy, gluten-free, and cholesterol-free, making it an accessible choice for all sorts of coffee drinkers.

And if this flavor’s return is any indication, 2025 is shaping up to be a big year for Coffee mate fans, with the brand also teasing its new Cold Foam collection and Xtra Flavor line.

So, is PB&J-flavored coffee the craving you didn’t know you had? Starting next year, you’ll get the chance to find out.