Best Pinot Noir 2024 | tried and tested

Pinot noir needs a coolish climate. Outside of Burgundy, high quality examples are made in Chile, New Zealand, Australia (particularly Tasmania), Oregon, California, Germany, Austria, and increasingly in England. The grape is also grown elsewhere in France, especially in the Loire.

We tasted a variety of samples from all over the world with a £25 maximum so we could include some burgundy worth drinking. Overall, the quality was extremely variable. Unlike say malbec, buying an affordable pinot noir is a hit-or-miss affair. Some of the Californian ones were unpleasantly jammy, whereas others had the opposite problem being vegetal and bitter. The best countries for value are Romania at the bottom end, Chile, France outside of Burgundy and Germany. With pinot, it’s always worth spending a bit more if you can.

Best pinot noir at a glance

Best premium New Zealand Pinot Noir: Nautilus Pinot Noir 2019, £24.45
Best Burgundy: Bourgogne Hautes-Côtes de Beaune, Clos de la Perrière, Domaine Sébastien Magnien 2020, £25.50
Best Loire Pinot: Sancerre Rouge Moulin Bèle Domaine André Vatan 2022, £21
Best German Pinot Noir: Neiss Spätburgunder 2020, £18.50
Best English Pinot Noir: Lyme Bay Pinot Noir 2021, £26.95
Best Chilean Pinot Noir: Errazuriz Pinot Noir Reserva 2023, £8.49
Best New Zealand Pinot Noir: Esk Valley Pinot Noir 2021, £18
Best budget French Pinot Noir: Puy-de-Dome Pinot Noir 2022, £14.50
Best budget Pinot Noir: Balauri Pinot Noir, Cramele Recaș 2022, £7.99
Best party Pinot Noir: The Society’s French Pinot Noir Bag in Box 2023, £22

Best pinot noir to buy 2024

Nautilus Pinot Noir 2019

Available from Vinvm (£24.45), Wine Direct (£25.70)

Best premium New Zealand pinot noir

Kiwi pinot noir starts to get seriously good if you can stretch to more than £20 a bottle. This is ripe and heady with notes of maraschino cherry, herbs and cinnamon with savoury leather notes on the finish. This sheer class.

Available from:

Bourgogne Hautes-Côtes de Beaune, Clos de la Perrière, Domaine Sébastien Magnien 2020

Available from Berry Bros & Rudd (£25.50)

Best burgundy

Red burgundy starts to get interesting above £20, I’m afraid. This is about as close to a bargain as you’re going to get. It’s delicate with crunchy red fruit and unmistakable violet note.

Available from:

Sancerre Rouge Moulin Bèle Domaine André Vatan 2022

Available from Yapp Bros (£21), Vivino (£26)

Best Loire pinot noir

Sancerre is famous for its white wines made from sauvignon blanc but the pinot noirs can be extremely good, too. This is ripe, silky, fresh, with red cherry fruit. In short, this is a lovely fragrant light pinot at a reasonable price.

Available from:

Neiss Spätburgunder 2020

Available from Fortnum and Mason (£18.50)

Best German pinot noir

The Germans have their own word for pinot noir, Spatburgunder, which means late ripening Burgundian. And they can be very good indeed as this example shows. With its flavours of ripe strawberry, clove and delicate floral notes, this is worth every penny.

Available from:

Lyme Bay Pinot Noir 2021

Available from Devon Hampers (£26.95), The English Wine Collection (£27)

Best English pinot noir

This one sneaks slightly over the £25 budget, but it’s worth it. This is made from grapes grown in the Crouch Valley in Essex. 2021 was a cold, wet vintage but you’d never guess from tasting this. There’s positively Californian levels of ripeness with a herbal and spicy finish.

Available from:

Errazuriz Pinot Noir Reserva 2023

Available from Waitrose (£8.49), Tesco (£9)

Best Chilean pinot noir

Chile makes some great pinot noirs from entry-level wines like this, up to serious wines that can give burgundy a run for its money. I’ve had a few vintages of this and it’s always reliably juicy and delicious with flavours of raspberry and cinnamon. Another one that tastes good cold.

Available from:

Esk Valley Pinot Noir 2021

Available from Cambridge Wine Merchants (£18)

Best New Zealand pinot noir

Marlborough, known for its sauvignon blancs, also produces some very tasty pinot noir. This is a more full-bodied expression of the grape with bittersweet black cherries, a herbal rosemary note and leathery tannins. We think it would be lovely with a roast leg of lamb.

Available from:

Puy-de-Dome Pinot Noir 2022

Available from Lea & Sandeman (£14.50)

Best budget French pinot noir

One of the great bargains of the wine world, this comes from the Auvergne which is nearly in the middle of France, just to the west of Lyon. It’s full, spicy and crammed with dark cherry fruit, nothing at all like burgundy and completely irresistible.

Available from:

Balauri Pinot Noir, Cramele Recaș 2022

Available from Click N Drink (£7.99)

Best budget pinot noir

This is made from a French grape in Romania in a winery owned by an Englishman. Cramele Recaș has established itself as the destination for affordable pinot noir. This is light and juicy with a nice raspberry fruit quality – it would be delicious served cool on a warm evening.

Available from:

The Society’s French Pinot Noir Bag in Box 2023

Available from The Wine Society (£22)

Best party pinot noir

This works out at about £7.33 a bottle. You’re not going to find a nice pinot noir for cheaper. And very tasty it is, too. It comes from grapes grown in a cooler part of the Languedoc to produce a wine that is spicy and soft with an earthy beetroot type quality.

Available from:

More wine content

The complete wine varieties guide
Why you should keep red wine in the fridge
Why you should be drinking Chilean wine
Why you should be drinking Mediterranean wine
Best wines to drink with pasta
How to choose the best Pinot Noir

If you have any questions, suggestions for future reviews or spot anything that has changed in price or availability please get in touch at goodfoodwebsite@immediate.co.uk.

What do you think of our selection of best pinot noir wines? Do you have a favourite bottle to recommend? We’d love to hear your product suggestions in the comments below…

Source link