60+ Ice Cream Products Recalled Due to Possible Listeria Risk

The U.S. Food & Drug Administration issued a recall on Totally Cool, Inc. ice cream products due to the risk of the products being contaminated with Listeria monocytogenes. The contamination was found during an FDA sampling.

Totally Cool, Inc. makes and distributes ice cream products for many brands, including Friendly’s, Hershey’s Ice Cream, Jeni’s and Cumberland Farms (see full list below). The affected products were distributed nationwide. The company has ceased production and distribution of the affected products and continues its investigation into the cause of the contamination.

Listeria is a bacteria that can be potentially fatal, especially in young children, frail or elderly people and people with weakened immune systems. Signs of listeria infection include high fever, severe headache, stiffness, nausea, abdominal pain and diarrhea. No illnesses have been reported to date. 

If you have any recalled items, return them to the store of purchase for a full refund. Recalled products can be identified by comparing the date and plant information on the product—see the full list below. For questions or concerns, contact Totally Cool, Inc. directly at 410-363-7801 or regulatory@totallycoolicecream.com.

Here’s the full list of brands and products affected by the recall, including best-by dates and codes.

• Friendly’s: 60 fl oz Celebration Ice Cream Cake, 40 fl oz Strawberry Krunch Ice Cream Cake; All dates between 5/20/2024 to 5/28/2025; Plant Code: 24-65, 24-0065, 2465, 240065 
• Abilyn’s Frozen Bakery: Vanilla & Chocolate 30 fl oz 6” Ice Cream Cake, Vanilla & Chocolate 60 fl oz 8” Ice Cream Cake, “For Love of Chocolate” Ice Cream Cake, “Cookies & Cream” Ice Cream Cake, “Cookie Dough” Ice Cream Cake; All best by dates between 5/20/2024 to 5/28/2025
• Hershey’s Ice Cream: 38 fl oz vanilla and chocolate flavored ice cream cake, 110 fl oz vanilla and chocolate flavored ice cream cake, 4 fl oz Cookies & Cream Ice Cream Cones, 4 fl oz Cookies & Cream Polar Bear Ice Cream Sandwiches; All codes between 2305140 to 2405170 (cakes), 3174 to 4047 (cones), 2307187 to 2406163 (sandwiches); Plant Codes: 24-65, 24-0065, 2465, 240065
• Yelloh!: 4 fl oz Vanilla Nut Ice Cream Sundae Cones, 4 fl oz Vanilla Fudge Ice Cream Sundae Cones, 4 fl oz Pecan Praline Ice Cream Sundae Cones, 4 fl oz Chip & Mint Ice Cream Sundae Cones, 4 fl oz Cookies & Cream Ice Cream Sandwiches, 4 fl oz Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches; All codes between 6T3227 to 6T4157 (cones), 6T3115 to 6T4171 (sandwiches)
• Jeni’s: 3.5 fl oz Chocolate Silk Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches, 3.5 fl oz Key Lime Pie Frozen Dessert, 3.5 fl oz Mint Chocolate Truffle Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches, 3.5 fl oz Triple Berry Tart Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches; All codes between 23205 to 24144; Plant Codes: 24-65, 24-0065, 2465, 240065 
• Cumberland Farms: 4 fl oz Rich Vanilla Farmhouse Premium Ice Cream Sandwich, 4 fl oz Marvelous Mint Premium Ice Cream Sandwich; all codes between 113025 to 120425
• The Frozen Farmer: 4 fl oz Elf on the Shelf Santa’s Cookies Ice Cream Sandwiches, 16 fl oz Elf on the Shelf Santa’s Cookies, 16 fl oz Strawberry Sorbet Pints, 16 fl oz Raspberry Sorbet Pints, 16 fl oz Orange Cream Frobert Pints, 16 fl oz Watermelon Sorbet Pints; All codes between 090425 to 120725 (sandwiches), 090525 to 073026 (pints); Plant Code: 24-65, 24-0065, 2465, 240065 
• Marco: 3.8 fl oz Dulce De Leche Ice Cream Sandwiches, 3.8 fl oz Vanilla Chai Ice Cream Sandwiches, 16 fl oz Dulce De Leche & Cookies Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Turkish Mocha Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Vanilla Chai Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Peanut Butter Caramel Ice Cream pints (regular and spicy), 16 fl oz Moroccan Honey Nut Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Green Tea White Chocolate Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Aztec Chocolate Ice Cream Pints; All codes between 112825 to 112925 (sandwiches), 060724 to 121125 (pints); Plant Code: 24-65, 24-0065, 2465, 240065 
• ChipWich: 4 fl oz The Original Vanilla Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich 10 Club Pack, 3 Pack, 24 Pack, 16 fl oz Vanilla Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Pint, 16 fl oz Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Pint; all codes between best by dates: 02/23/25 to 12/21/25 (sandwiches), 07/25/24 to 01/27/25 (Pints); Club pack (10 units): Lot# 23298-24172, Single Serve: Lot# 23298-24164; 3 packs: Lot# 23298-24136; With Plant Code: 24-65, 24-0065, 2465, 240065 
• AMAFruits: 3 gal Acai Sorbet Tubs, 3 gal Dragon Fruit Sorbet Tubs; All Codes: 32824, 32924, 33024, 50125, 50225 50325 50425 62725 62825 62925 63025 60125 72825 82825 82925 83125 90525 2311324 2311325 2311326 2311331 2311332 2311333 2311334 2401031 2401032 2401033 2401036 2401037 2401038 2401039 2401040 2402043 2402044 2402057 2402058 402059 2403085 2403086 2403087 2403088 2404120 2404121 2405142 2406158 2406159; With Plant Code: 24-65, 24- 0065, 2465, 240065 
• Taharka: 16 fl oz Honey Graham Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Key Lime Pie Ice Cream Pints; Code: 100125; With Plant Code: 24-65, 24-0065, 2465, 240065  
• Dolcezza Gelato: 16 fl oz Mascarpone & Berries Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Roasted Strawberry Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Peanut Butter Mash and Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Dulce de Leche & Cookies Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Stracciatella Ice Cream Pints,16 fl oz Peanut Stracciatella Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Swiss Chocolate Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Coffee & Cookies Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Hot Cocoa Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Sugar Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Dark Chocolate Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Dark Chocolate Fudge Ice Cream Pints; all codes between 052024 to 062025; With Plant Code 24-65, 24-0065, 2465, 240065  
• LaSalle: 16 fl oz Chocolate Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Vanilla Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Cherry Vanilla Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Vanilla Mango Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Vanilla Raspberry Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Vanilla Fudge Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Dulce De Leche Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Cookies & Cream Ice Cream Pints, 16 fl oz Butter Pecan Ice Cream Pints; all codes between 111824 to 102525; Plant Code 24-65, 24-0065, 2465, 240065