The $6 Walmart Bakery Item Fans ‘Need to Get Their Hands On’

If you’re in need of a tasty, inexpensive treat, Walmart’s bakery is a great place to find it. It’s the very spot for those super-fresh Pumpkin Cake Rolls we grabbed at the start of 2024’s cozy season and the No-Bake Blueberry Cheesecake cups that were perfect when we were longing for a sweet fix this summer.

But don’t just take our word for it. Last fall, the bakery’s mini Strawberry Butter Cakes were so good that fans left the store speechless. 

This season, there’s a new treat in town we believe will be equally enticing. Its flavor throws back to a childhood favorite, so it’s sure to conjure up some comfort, too. Hint: Uncrustable fans like Travis Kelce will go crazy over this news.

Walmart Debuts PB&J Cake

Instagram food reviewer @morganchomps recently spotted a new PB&J cake at Walmart’s bakery. The 5-inch cake appears to cost just under $6, although the price may vary depending on the location.

The round yellow cake has a layer of peanut butter frosting and strawberry jelly, stirring up some serious nostalgia. “It tastes like you made a peanut butter and jelly sandwich, but you use sheet cake in place of bread,” she said.

Our minds are blown.

We’re not the only ones intrigued. Commenters on the Instagram post said that it “sounds amazing” and that they must get their “hands on this thing.” Some were floored because they “didn’t know this was a thing” and planned to head to Walmart as soon as possible.

One commenter said they’d be all in if the cake was available with grape jelly (so far, we’ve only seen it with strawberry). Either way, we think a childhood favorite in cake form is sure to bring back some fond memories—at a very sweet price.